Beth and Michelle revisit Ivan Reitman's Dave expecting the charming political comedy they remembered and instead find themselves having one of their most passionate conversations yet. What once felt like a lighthearted story about an ordinary man stepping into extraordinary circumstances now raises uncomfortable questions about power, democracy, constitutional norms, and how dramatically the world has changed since 1993.
Alongside Kevin Kline's endlessly lovable performance, they explore why Dave himself remains so easy to root for even as the situation surrounding him becomes increasingly difficult to ignore. The discussion wanders through political ethics, public service, found integrity, and the difference between a good person and a good system, while also celebrating the warmth that Kevin Kline and Sigourney Weaver bring to the film's unlikely romance.
The episode closes with the Castellini Test, where Beth and Michelle discover that Dave fails not only on representation, but also prompts a bigger conversation about whether any single test can fully capture what makes a film feel equitable. That question would go on to shape the way they approached movie criticism for years to come.